Damn Tim u mad? lol. (That article)

Well, I haven't watched every single season (I didn't see the one with Ashley). I don't remember having a problem with Anya winning.

I really did not like Gretchen or her clothing, so I was pretty mad when she won.

Besides Gretchen, the other one I got irrationally angry about was Leanne Marshall winning. I don't recall who she was up against but I was SO MAD I almost boycotted watching the show. I guess I felt they were just ...not good, very amateurish, looked like those ice bags to put on your head when you have a headache, etc. Just random swoops on each one. It just seemed like something a child would come up with. I was so mad!! It's funny though because I see comments since then citing hers as one of the best etc. I dont' get it, I still don't get it, I will never get it. Maybe she's done good stuff since then, but that collection was so not good. Again, it just seemed very one-note, uncreative and amateurish. I was so baffled that she won. That's my story and I'm stickin to it

(And do we all agree that Christian Siriano was the best to come out of this show lol?)

@blacknyellowsquid said:

Damn Tim u mad? lol. (That article)

I know. Right? Ashley isn't owning that it's about her.

Well, I haven't watched every single season (I didn't see the one with Ashley). I don't remember having a problem with Anya winning.

She couldn't even sew and what she did make were maxi dresses.

I really did not like Gretchen or her clothing, so I was pretty mad when she won.

I came in during the middle of the season to see the travesty of Gretchen winning.

Besides Gretchen, the other one I got irrationally angry about was Leanne Marshall winning.

I didn't see that season.

(And do we all agree that Christian Siriano was the best to come out of this show lol?)

Didn't see that season either.

You guys picked exactly the four I would have chosen as the worst. Gretchen, LeeAnn, Ashley and Anya.

My rankings, least to most bad:

1. Gretchen. I didn't like her collection at all, remember the granny pantie shorts? But she did have a point of view.
2. Ashley. I didn't hate her collection as much as most people did, but it wasn't good.
   
3. LeeAnn. Petals, petals, petals, oh my.
4. Anya. Her collection consisted of about 8 maxi dresses with exactly the same neckline, and a couple of swim suits. Josh was robbed.

I didn't even see petals, I saw hospital materials. An enema device (do those have a name?), the bag you put on your head or a sprained ankle with ice...I looked her up just to see what she's doing, and she has some wedding dresses now that look nice. So I guess she got better. But I really did not like nor "get" her collection at ALL. (LeAnne). I remember being really really angry, my mom was even like calm down lol

No clear winner yet?

If I had to pick, I will have to say Ashley, because she hot glued flowers to a skirt and topped it off with a crop top. Tim Gun went in detail, and you know if you make Tim mad because you won... then that's a first.

Seriously, folks!

https://az616578.vo.msecnd.net/files/2016/09/11/636092167499940572-1562524672_Ashley%20Nell%20tipton%20finale%20looks%202.jpg

OK, thanks for the reminder with visual about Ashley. Yup, those were bad. She gets my vote.

Still Leanne for me. but maybe if I watched the whole season with Ashley, I'd somehow feel differently?

@jonnieblack said:

OK, thanks for the reminder with visual about Ashley. Yup, those were bad. She gets my vote.

It's a pity that she couldn't do better. It's not one look that appears to be high fashion.

I remember being surprised at her collection, not in a good way. She did well in several of the challenges.

@jonnieblack said:

I remember being surprised at her collection, not in a good way. She did well in several of the challenges.

Yeah, I liked her first win, but it was a crop top.