Jay Pharoah, Inbar Lavi, Rob Riggle and Sherri Shepherd must guess the identities of a sperm donor, a hoop dancing champion, a real hypnotist (who hypnotizes Mama Doris), a slight-of-hand magician and a female baseball hall of famer.

The panel is presented with a variety of participants with interesting stories, from the Rubik’s Cube foot-solving record-holder to a vocal coach for the stars and a husband-calling champion.