Timmy meets his favorite superhero, The Crimson Chin, but the discovery that he is fictional sends the hero into a deep depression. Timmy must now reverse this situation, and as a result, he gains the superhero alter-ego of Cleft the Boy Chin Wonder.

Timmy becomes suspicious of a rich boy named Remy when he notices that he can be better than him in many situations. Timmy eventually learns that he has a fairy godparent.

Timmy wants to get a new Crimson Chin comic while bathing, so he wishes himself there, but appears in the nude and must run all the way back home naked. Meanwhile, inside the comic book Timmy left behind, the Crimson Chin fights H20lga!

Timmy is an stunt-boy in the Crimson Chin movie where he uncovers a plot to discredit the Chin.

When Catman becomes depressed because no one in Dimmsdale appreciates his brand of cat-themed justice, Timmy wishes him into the world of the Crimson Chin.

Timmy wishes for Magician powers to attract everyone to his parents yard, but this has unintended consequences.

Timmy's disappointed to see how boring the Crimson Chin comics have become lately. When he spends a day with the Chin, he sees why - the Chin is lonely. Timmy wishes up a super girlfriend for him, except now the comic is both boring and romantic, yuck! Desperate, Timmy unknowingly makes a wish that changes everything, so he must undo his wish - and fast.

Timmy Turner makes his millionth wish which all of Fairy World has gathered to celebrate. But after reviewing his wishes, the Fairy Council finds that Timmy should be put on trial for being the worst godkid ever! Wanda, Cosmo, and Poof think they can prove that Timmy's a good kid, until the truth comes out—Timmy made a secret wish that no one knows about, not even his godfamily.