Nicole is upset with Yonk's one-year anniversary present when, instead of something meaningful, he gives her a stripper pole. Meanwhile, Kat is peeved by her new neighbor, a former classmate that her sister and Ethan seem to get along with.

When Ethan's date confesses that she has always had a crush on Kat, he imagines one of his biggest fantasies coming true. Meanwhile, Lina, Nicole and Duncan visit Richie's rough neighborhood to help him collect things from his apartment, and the group has an unfortunate run in with Fern and a gun.

When Palmer overhears a phone conversation between Kat and Benjamin that insinuates that her relationship with Ethan is based solely on sex, she decides they need to practice abstinence and discover what else they have in common.

Lina's friends are disgusted when she cooks a special recipe for her dinner party and they are forced to eat inedible Moroccan chicken to not hurt her feelings.

Valentine's Day is meant to be spent with those you love, but the holiday is anything but that when a snowstorm hits Philadelphia and strands the former classmates at each other's homes.

When Duncan and Richie finish repairs on her home, Nicole is surprised by how upset she feels at not having them around.