While at a carnival, Gary and Wyatt see a hot girl, Valerie, and have a falling out when they fight over her. Lisa zaps the boys into the carnival funhouse and leaves them there until they can stop fighting. They have fun opening mysterious doors trying to find Valerie, and Wyatt seems to get all the good ones- he even gets a puppy out of it. In the end, the guys both get dissed by Valerie as she chooses an evil funhouse clown over the both of them.

Lisa zaps Wyatt out of existence to see what life would have been without him...and it doesn't seem too bad.

Lisa helps bring Wyatt's dream girl to life, but also whips up a monster intent on eating Chett and Gary.